曹豫生   草根首页 | 设为首页 | 加入收藏
管窥社会 - 曹豫生首页
说说《北平无战事》
2014-10-23
字号:
这几天在网上看《北平无战事》,一口气看了二十几集,此剧高开低走,我不知道能否保持兴趣最后看完,仅就看过的说说自己的直观感受。

  一、驾轻就熟

  看了媒体报道知道此剧编剧是以前编《大明王朝1566》的那位,那么编写此剧并不是很费力气的,原因就在于《北平无战事》是《大明王朝》的民国翻版,都是统治后期面对政策,案件和民情等尖锐矛盾,各种势力展开的明争暗斗。这两剧的框架基本是一样的,就像好莱坞系列电影《死神来了》一样,故事框架基本一样,无非就是各种不同的死法而已。《大明王朝》是明朝内部的斗争,而《北平无战事》是国民党内部的斗争,当然还有共产党,但是实话实说,共产党在这部戏里是一条副线,其实就是把共产党的戏基本去掉,不影响故事的主要情节发展,共产党在此剧里基本就是凑热闹的。这个故事之所以吸引群众,就在于“明争暗斗”,实际上也就是“宫斗”这类东西的政治领域的翻版,真正想从剧中去探索历史兴衰的人,怕是寥寥无几。因为写过《大明王朝》,作者写此剧实际上已经有了很多的套路,如果套路熟了,以后此类剧作就会像宫斗,抗日神剧一样流水线生产了。

  二、人物设定和情节问题多

  此剧开头还是挺抓人的,可是后面就陷入了乱麻,反正我的智商不够,有点理不清了。很多人物设定我感觉都是有问题的,比如说刘烨扮演的方孟敖,剧中很多人都夸他是个人才,很聪明等等,可是我愣是一点没看出来,我看到的方孟敖就是个两“二”——二杆子加二百五——横冲直撞,牛气哄哄,肆意妄为,可不知为什么,剧作无论各类高官还是各种手下,还是他的家人,都让他三分,就好像他是总统或建丰同志附体一样。真有一种人人都爱方孟敖的味道。至少我看此剧至今,还没看他干什么聪明的事,只看到他莽撞的很,也许后面他会突然智商和情商提高,也说不定,但是我未必看到了。

  还有可达同志,开始一副精明强干的样子,自从到了北平,智商迅速走低。比如给建丰同志打电话,开始还是一些大事和原则性的问题,打电话请示无可厚非,可是越往后,屁大点的事都要打电话请示,事太小且打电话过于频繁,这就不合常理了,后来又冒出个蒲忱同志,也是频繁的打电话,这两个活宝是要累死建丰同志的节奏啊,想想全国多少个“可达同志”、“蒲忱同志”这么给建丰同志打电话,建丰同志在大陆就得累死了。可达同志后来好像除了打电话以外,基本上就没戏了。

  刘烨同志扮演的方孟敖同志,其种种行为我完全找不到逻辑支撑,就迷惑于他在剧作到底要干什么,能干什么。要么是我智力不足,不能理解编导的深意,要么是编导其实也不清楚,就是想让他看起来很“酷”,可我只看到了两“二”,后来我发现方孟敖只是代表人物,剧中很多人物的行为我都没有找到逻辑支撑,比如崔中石为什么要找死,按照正常的逻辑,他共产党的身份的曝光,不是会增加特务们对和他很亲近的方孟敖的身份的怀疑吗?这类疑惑多了,我有点想弃剧。

  三、探索历史兴衰

  中国人讲“势”,当一个王朝形成了开始走下坡路的“势”的时候,是非常难以挽救的,要把这个“势”扭转过来,绝非常人可以的。崇祯皇帝最后上吊,是他的先辈们形成了亡国的“势”,崇祯再努力也是百搭。当然这个“势”的形成,也是一个过程,像隋炀帝那样一代就形成了这个“势”并且直接亡了国,说明隋炀帝也是非常能干的,如果他是一个平庸无奇的皇帝,隋朝时间可能更长一些。正因为这个认识,我挺佩服张居正的,因为他在明朝向下走的大势已经形成的情况下,居然部分的扭转局面,有了中兴的气势,可惜他一死,这个局面就不可收拾了。

  老蒋大概是个崇祯式的人物,虽然努力,但是终究无力扭转大势。而建丰同志有张居正之志,却无张居正之能,也无张居正之权,终究只是个聪明能干的常人而已。

  《北平无战事》当然是要“借古喻今”,但今天的局面毕竟是老蒋当时无法比的,共产党如能励精图治,建立并保持中国向上走的“势”,腐败就只是个小问题,如果有了向下走的“势”,腐败就是催命符。

微信订阅号:caogenzhiku

所有文章只代表作者观点,与本站立场无关!
  • Or I copy it from you? ha.
    2015/7/1 8:59:27
  • Sylvia,
    Where does that line(28楼) come from?
    It sounds Shakespearean to me, or better still, Sylviaan.
    2015/7/1 1:43:35
  • Valentine is here, how could Sylvia not be.
    2015/6/30 7:55:21
  • What light is light, if Sylvia be not seen?
    What joy is joy, if Sylvia be not by?
    Unless it be to think she is by
    And feed upon the shadow of perfection.
    Except I be with Sylvia in the night,
    There is no music in the nightingale.
    Unless I look on Sylvia in the day,
    There is no day for me to look upon.
    (Two Gentlemen of Verona Act 3, Scene 1, Shakespeare)
    2015/6/30 0:14:54
  • Sylvia,
    They did it because they could.
    Reason is not the element used in China to negotiate a path forward, power is.
    It's a Chinese philosophy.
    2015/6/17 9:25:50
  • What Horatio done to let them delete the file? Don‘t tell me only because he post some words for Sylvia.
    Anyway, deleting files/posts are so normal in China, it happens here, it happens in 新浪微博....everywhere. 中国特色.
    2015/6/17 8:36:43
  • Sylvia,
    Make a long story short:
    A couple of days ago, a member of 草根管理员 felt grossly offended by some of my words, so much so that he disqualified me to publish my words here(my words couldn't be sent out).
    The situation lasted for two or three days, and during this period of time, I shot two emails out for help, one to 草根's management team, asking for an explanation, and another to 老汪, pleading for a favor. Neither responded. In despair, I was even wondering if I should have offered 老汪 to mop his floor in exchange for his help.
    As the hope of getting "shalako" back was fading, I started to prepare myself for losing it for good, and think about registering a different name. In fact I did two, Horatio as the main one, and Vito Corleone as the insurance. Vito didn't get a chance to see the light for a second, but Horatio did lead a short yet glorious life by making one comment here:
    ["What light is light, if Sylvia be not seen?
    What joy is joy, if Sylvia be not by?"
    -- the reason for me to have crawled back.]
    Then Horatio was gone, together with his words. That was the darkest moment I had ever experienced here. No, I take it back. It was the second darkest moment, with the daylight hardly seen between it and the first though.
    But soon and mysteriously, "shalako" popped back up, which, I gathered, was due to 老汪’s help, or the combination of both 老汪's help and the management team's effort.  
    I sent 老汪 a thank-you email, with the offer of "mopping his floor" mentioned not though.
    That's the story, since then, the sail has been pretty smooth.
    2015/6/16 10:44:17
  • Shalako,
    I thought something happened when I couldn‘t see your name there, but there‘s no email. That‘s a power talk, right?
    2015/6/15 7:58:30
  • Sylvia,
    I got a new name, Horatio, only for a short period of time though. Horatio was blocked and the words written under Horatio were deleted.
    But I've got "shalako" back. I'd say it is a good trade.
    2015/6/13 10:20:58
  • Sylvia,
    I remember a line said by Forrest: “You were“.
    2015/6/10 9:32:50
  • What I have written on [10楼] is short, yet is also all I can say about it.
    ......................
    I remember there‘s a line from Forrest Gump, he said, “that is all I can say about Vietnam“.
    2015/6/10 7:12:03
  • Sylvia,
    I tried, with a couple of drafts, to write more about Forrest Gump, but failed.
    What I have written on [10楼] is short, yet is also all I can say about it.
    2015/6/9 10:11:19
评分与评论 真差 一般 值得一看 不错 太棒了
姓名 
联系方式
  评论员用户名 密码 注册为评论员
最新通过审核的评论员: 56yidi   ABC之音   yangfw   浪尘2016   大禹治水   zhangyanxia   lisha864   哇哈哈160   kingfire   yinuo0822
   发贴后,本网站会记录您的IP地址。请注意,根据我国法律,网站会将有关您的发帖内容、发帖时间以及您发帖时的IP地址的记录保留至少60天,并且只要接到合法请求,即会将这类信息提供给有
关机构。详细使用条款>>
草根简介


大学时学的理工科,毕业后也从事的是技术工作,芸芸众生中的普通一员。我希望了解社会,思考社会。把自己对社会的所思所想写下了,尽量给大家一个不同于主流的视角。联系方式cyspds@gmail.com
最新评论 更多>>

最新文章 更多>>
关于我们  联系我们:QQ513460486 邮箱:icaogen@126.com
CopyRight © 2006-2013 www.caogen.com All Rights Reserved 浙ICP备11047994号